Karen Lee Torre

Karen Lee Torre, a New Haven trial lawyer, litigates civil rights issues in the federal court. Her e-mail address is thimbleislands@att.net.

Legally Conservative

Repeat Offender Judges

Last week, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a notable opinion in iWong v. Belmontes,/i summarily reversing a divided panel of (big surprise) the Ninth Circuit. It's notable for the sole reason that this was the third time the Supreme Court had to take up this case. Belmontes brutally bludgeoned a woman to death. His reason? To steal and sell her stereo for the $100 he needed for beer and drugs that night. Justly sentenced to death, Belmontes has been continually mollycoddled by "arch activist" Judge Stephen Reinhardt.

Legally Conservative

Listening To Victims

I arrived in Washington D.C. last Wednesday morning to see the same front page headline in all the local newspapers announcing the State of Virginia had carried out the execution of mass murderer John Allen Muhammad. Known as the "D.C. sniper," Muhammad (not his real name, of course) and a sidekick terrorized the citizenry during a shooting spree in the greater D.C. area, randomly choosing victims, gunning them down as they were going about such ordinary activities as shopping or getting gas at a filling station.

Legally Conservative

Candid Cameras In The Courtroom

I got used to the media. Over the years, they covered many of my cases because they involved either a crooked politician, an issue of interest to the public, or both. But that meant print reporters sitting in on my trials and TV cameras waiting for me outside the courthouse (and in recent months, on the front lawn of my home.) But not inside the courtroom while I worked. Big difference.

Legally Conservative

The Cy Pres Racket

The cy pres doctrine sorely needs reform. Hopefully, the U.S. Supreme Court will take the first opportunity to rein it in, or Congress should do it. (Don't count on the Democrats).

Legally Conservative

Leisure Reading Judge Jacobs

I make it a habit to scan the opinions and summary orders of the Second Circuit Court of Appeals. I do it to keep abreast of the law in my areas of interest, and so I typically focus only on civil rights cases. But I often expand my reads and play games for amusement. For example, in race, gender and other discrimination cases, I'll read all summary orders in addition to published opinions. To test my own (widely shared) views regarding the outcome-oriented approach of certain of that court's members, I'll deliberately skip over the identity of the panelists, read the opinion or order and then guess who the author or panelists are. That I am so frequently correct in my presumptions is both gratifying and depressing.

Legally Conservative

The First Amendment And The Dysfunctional DEP

For public employees who suffer harassment and other retaliation by government officials for what they say or write, a recent opinion of the Second Circuit Court of Appeals should provide more redress for the victims of abusive bureaucrats. In iSousa v. Roque/i, the Second Circuit clarified a prong of First Amendment law that has long muddled the jurisprudence and produced inconsistent outcomes in the district courts.

Legally Conservative

In Praise Of Innocence

Over the years, I have had outcomes in cases that gave rise to self-pride, smiles and a great night's sleep. They make up for the ones that keep you up half the night or make you bite your tongue to keep from telling an insufferable client to - well, you know. Sometimes, the best moments for a lawyer come in cases that are not about winning a seven-figure verdict or even an acquittal in a criminal case, for an acquittal does not necessarily mean you saved an innocent person from conviction.

Legally Conservative

A Year Of Reader Feedback

I never thought so many people would read my column but at every court, bar event or party, I get approached by lawyers and judges with something to say about this or that column. I get e-mails from readers all the time and all but a few write to say they agreed with whatever I said. But even those who disagree strongly are quite open-minded correspondents. Thankfully, I have received no abusive messages and many readers have engaged me in thoughtful debates that I thoroughly enjoyed.